Accenture has announced that it is launching a programmatic services offering – a move that fundamentally threatens its impartiality as a media auditor.
Accenture announces programmatic services offering
Last week Accenture, best known in advertising circles for its media auditing business, announced that its digital arm, Accenture Interactive, was launching a programmatic services practice. Accenture Interactive Programmatic Services will offer services in three areas: programmatic consulting and in-housing; media strategy, planning and activation; and ad tech implementation and support. In doing so, they have placed themselves in direct competition with both media agencies and a wide range of specialist companies that already offer programmatic planning and buying services.
The claim: more transparency
They claim that they have launched this service in response to an increasing trend amongst advertisers of bringing programmatic spend – at least partially – in-house, in order to regain control of their advertising investment in a time where transparency is a concern. The May 2018 ‘Programmatic In-housing’ report by the US Interactive Advertising Bureau found that 18% of marketers have moved their programmatic buying in its entirety in house, while another 47% have begun the process and intend to continue it. This can be a complicated process involving synchronisation of many previously disparate parts of an organisation, so advertisers are interested in somebody who can help them manage the process with 100% transparency, which Accenture claims it will provide.
The reality: less impartiality
Many media and specialist programmatic agencies have expressed profound concerns about a conflict of interest, with some saying that they will no longer accept Accenture audits. We at ECI agree. The key to effective media auditing is impartiality, and no company can legitimately claim to be impartial whilst offering media services to a market where it has highly privileged access to the data and financial information of both advertisers and agencies. You cannot provide independent benchmarking as an auditor if you are also buying inventory. As Paul Bainsfair, the Director General of the IPA (the UK ad industry’s trade body) said, the move is “incompatible with [Accenture’s] role as a media auditor… In an era where transparency is under the spotlight, this self-evident conflict of interest is unacceptable”.
Accenture has defended its impartiality by claiming that will not provide both auditing and media services to the same client, and that, as Accenture Interactive is a separate business unit to the media auditing business, firewalls and confidentiality agreements will be in place. We have doubts that, in practice, this will be effective. As one media agency boss said, what’s to stop them telling prospect clients that their agency is non-transparent and that they have the solution?
- 5G is coming – here’s what it means for marketers December 10, 2018 - AT&T and Verizon have announced 5G-enabled smartphones with Samsung for 2019 - 5G is here. Where will the new super-fast mobile internet connectivity take us? Read more
- Martin Sorrell’s ambitions for S4 Capital reflect a changing industry November 29, 2018 - Tools and technology are dramatically transforming the communications industry - and S4 Capital is a reflection of that. Read more
- How smart speakers are changing the way we search and shop November 22, 2018 - This Black Friday many consumers will be purchasing a smart speaker. How will it change their behaviour and how should brands respond? Read more
- The evolution of the role of the marketer – and what that means for the future of the industry November 16, 2018 - The marketers' role has changed dramatically over the last four decades. What can we learn from the changing questions that they must ask themselves? Read more
- Day 3 at the ANA Masters of Marketing October 28, 2018 - More inspiring content and ideas to take home from day 3 at the Masters of Marketing. Read more